Home
International Tax/Europe

22 Nov 2026

EU Challenges 8 Countries Over Pension Fund Tax Rules

EU Challenges 8 Countries Over Pension Fund Tax Rules

Last updated: November 2026 · Status: Confirmed

Europe · International tax · 19 November 2026

Newsletter

The TaxSpoc Brief

Free weekly brief: the tax stories that matter, for advisors and in-house tax teams.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.

On 19 November 2026, the European Commission opened infringement proceedings against eight Member States over the discriminatory taxation of foreign pension funds and life insurance companies (European Commission). The countries are Belgium, Germany, Spain, Italy, Austria, Poland, Portugal and Romania.

The Commission says their rules tax foreign pension funds and insurers more heavily than comparable domestic ones. In its view, this discourages cross-border investment and breaches the free movement of capital. For pension schemes and insurers investing across Europe, the case could eventually reopen withholding tax refunds in these countries.

EU infringement on pension fund taxation: at a glance

ItemDetail
Announced19 November 2026, November infringement package
StageLetters of formal notice (first step of the procedure)
Member StatesAustria, Belgium, Germany, Italy, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Spain
Who is affectedForeign pension funds and life insurance companies
Rules at issueTax on investment income; deduction of technical reserves
Legal basisArticle 63 TFEU and Article 40 EEA Agreement (free movement of capital)
Deadline to replyTwo months
Possible next stepReasoned opinion

Which countries is the Commission challenging?

The Commission sent letters of formal notice to seven Member States. Belgium received an additional letter that widens a case opened in 2020, so that it covers pension funds as well as life insurers.

Member StateCase referenceType of letter
AustriaINFR(2026)2177Letter of formal notice
BelgiumINFR(2020)4000Additional letter of formal notice
GermanyINFR(2026)4019Letter of formal notice
ItalyINFR(2026)2176Letter of formal notice
PolandINFR(2026)2178Letter of formal notice
PortugalINFR(2026)4018Letter of formal notice
RomaniaINFR(2026)2175Letter of formal notice
SpainINFR(2026)2172Letter of formal notice

What tax rules does the Commission say are discriminatory?

The Commission flags two ways national rules favour domestic institutions over comparable foreign ones.

IssueDomestic pension funds and life insurersComparable foreign institutions
Tax on investment income (dividends, interest)ExemptTaxed on income sourced in the country, usually through withholding tax
Deduction of technical reservesCan deduct reserves set aside for future liabilities to clientsCannot deduct them from taxable income

Technical reserves are the funds a pension fund or insurer sets aside to pay future pensions and claims. If only local institutions can deduct them, foreign ones pay tax on a larger base for the same activity. The combined effect is a higher tax burden on foreign investors, which the Commission says makes investing across borders less attractive than investing at home.

What is the legal basis for the infringement proceedings?

The Commission relies on the free movement of capital:

  • Article 63 TFEU prohibits restrictions on movements of capital between Member States, and between Member States and third countries.
  • Article 40 of the EEA Agreement extends the same freedom to Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway.

Under EU law, a Member State can tax residents and non-residents differently only where their situations are not objectively comparable, or where an overriding reason in the public interest justifies it. The Commission's position is that domestic and foreign pension funds and insurers are comparable, so the different treatment is a restriction.

What happens next?

The eight Member States have two months to reply. A letter of formal notice is only the first step of the infringement procedure under Article 258 TFEU:

  1. Letter of formal notice (stage reached on 19 November 2026): the Commission sets out its concerns and asks for a response.
  2. Reasoned opinion: if the reply is not satisfactory, the Commission formally asks the country to change its law within a set deadline.
  3. Referral to the Court of Justice of the EU: if the country still does not comply, the Commission can take the case to court.

Many cases close at the first or second stage, because the country amends its rules or the Commission accepts its explanation. At this point these are allegations of a breach of EU law, not court findings.

What does this mean for foreign pension funds and insurers?

Nothing changes in law yet, but institutions that invest in these eight countries can act now:

  1. Map your exposure. List dividend and interest income from these countries and the withholding tax paid on it.
  2. Protect refund rights. Withholding tax reclaims are subject to national time limits. Protective claims can keep earlier years open while the case runs.
  3. Document comparability. Gather evidence that your fund or insurer is comparable to a domestic one: regulatory status, purpose and tax treatment at home.
  4. Watch the timeline. Replies are due within two months. A reasoned opinion would signal the Commission is pressing ahead.

Refund procedures and deadlines differ widely by country, so take local advice before filing. Find international tax advisers in the TaxSpoc Directory.

The bottom line

The EU wants pension savings and insurance capital to flow to the most productive investments anywhere in the bloc, a goal behind its Savings and Investments Union. Tax rules that favour domestic investors pull the other way. This package shows the Commission using infringement cases, not only new legislation, to remove those barriers. The open question is whether Europe can build a genuine single market for capital while national tax systems still favour domestic investors.

Frequently asked questions

Which countries is the EU challenging over pension fund taxation?

Belgium, Germany, Spain, Italy, Austria, Poland, Portugal and Romania, in the Commission's infringement package of 19 November 2026.

Why does the Commission say the rules are discriminatory?

Domestic pension funds and life insurers are exempt from tax on investment income and can deduct technical reserves. Comparable foreign institutions are taxed on local income and cannot deduct those reserves.

What EU law is allegedly breached?

The free movement of capital under Article 63 TFEU and Article 40 of the EEA Agreement.

How long do the Member States have to respond?

Two months from the letters of formal notice. If the replies are not satisfactory, the Commission may issue reasoned opinions.

Can foreign pension funds reclaim withholding tax?

Possibly, but nothing is decided yet. Funds that may be affected often file protective refund claims before national time limits expire, with advice for each country.

Is this a final ruling?

No. Letters of formal notice set out the Commission's view that the rules breach EU law. Only the Court of Justice of the EU can rule on that if the case reaches it.

Published by
TAXSPOC News Desk

TaxSpoc is a free platform sharing tax news, insights, and practical content with a growing Global Tax Community. Our goal is simple: democratize tax knowledge and make high-quality tax content accessible to everyone—no paywalls, no fluff.

For any questions, clarifications, contributions, or concerns related to this article, don’t hesitate to contact us at hello@taxspoc.com.